IEN logo

ALERTS!

Indigenous Environmental Network
INDIGENOUS
ENVIRONMENTAL
NETWORK

PO Box 485
Bemidji, MN 56619
tel: 218- 751-4967
fax: 218-751-0561
email ien@igc.org

 ALERTS ARCHIVES

  CONTACT US

  ABOUT IEN

  CAMPAIGNS

  HOME

 

February 28, 2007

DESERT ROCK UPDATE

28th, House Bill 178, the Desert Rock bill, which proposes to give an $85 million tax credit for a proposed coal-fired power plant on the Navajo reservation, was permanently tabled!

For the most up to date information about the Desert Rock Power Plant, please visit http://www.desert-rock-blog.com/.

 

Honor The Water, Respect The Water,
Be Thankful For The Water, Protect The Water

A CALL TO ACTION

Indigenous World Water

Day March 22, 2007

Indigenous Brothers And Sisters Struggling
To Defend The Ancestral Lands Of Indigenous Peoples

Free Trade Agreements and neo-liberalism have brought about a rapid expansion in economic globalisation in recent decades. We now see how poor and indebted countries look to the exploitation of natural resources as the solution to their economic problems. The wealthy and industrialized nations continue this resource exploitation within their own countries as well as continuing the resource incursions into other people’s lands in other parts of the world. In many cases, these resources are found on the ancestral lands of Indigenous Peoples. Mining, oil, gas, corporation agriculture, and water extraction, water privatisation and pollution are at the heart of many resource conflicts on and around Indigenous Lands throughout this Western Hemisphere. In the past, we have been marginalized in the decision-making processes that end up harming our People and the land we care for.

WE ARE NOT INVISIBLE

Our Indigenous Peoples and communities have known and demonstrated that we have the knowledge and capacity to take care of the Earth and various cultural and natural resources that we have been given. Governments and corporations have sought our Indigenous Traditional Ecological Knowledge that may be beneficial to their interests. When Indigenous and corporate interests collide, governments politically, socially, and economically isolate us into geo-political paradigms where we are forced to make decisions about the sanctioning exploitation of mineral and fossil fuel resources. In other situations, water and air pollution come from sources outside of our territories. This exploitation, privatisation and contamination upset the balance of cultural resources and sacred sites. As Indigenous Peoples and communities come to better understand the risks associated to resource exploitation, there is an increasing amount of resistance to project proposals and/or a growing demand for remediation of existing problems. This has had the effect of forcing governments and corporations to respond to our concerns.

WE HAVE THE POWER TO BRING CHANGE

INDIGENOUS WORLD WATER DAY is March 22. This is an invitation to your community to participate in an international event that will raise the Indigenous Voice in defence of Sacred Water. It consists of organizing in each community a public event according to your traditions and according to the unique forms of your people. We must illustrate to the national and international audience, and the media, that Indigenous Peoples are united to defend water in all places where it is threatened. We must demand clean up where it is polluted. We must promote laws that recognize the sacredness of water and inherent customary rights to water, by Indigenous Peoples. As these events take place in all regions of the Americas, we will remind the world of the role and responsibilities as Guardians and Protectors of Water that we, as the Original Peoples have played since the beginning of time. The world is out of balance; this is the moment to act on behalf of our Mother Earth, and the water that sustains all life.

It is important to invite the press to witness your event. We must speak individually and collectively to protect the water. Together let’s make an Indigenous Movement to protect water by forming a human chain holding containers of water or other types of ceremonies and celebrations throughout the Americas on Indigenous World Water Day.

NO MORE MINE WASTE, AGRICULTURAL WASTE, HUMAN WASTE, OR INDUSTRIAL WASTE IN OUR WATER

The Indigenous Environmental Network (www.ienearth.org), along with many elders and others who care about the legacy we leave for future generations bring this invitation to you. To add your voice to an international press release or more information about the event, and to inform us about the event to be held in your community, please communicate with:

Contact, IEN Mining Organizer, Robert Shimek, toll free US and Canada 1+ 877-436-2121 (1+- 218-751-4967) email rshimek@ienearth.org Or in Spanish Tamara@sextosol.org

 

Please distribute to all networks! Rally to Oppose Desert Rock Power Plant!
Feb 5, 2-3PM, 2007
Round House Rotunda (northwest corner of Paseo de Peralta and Old Santa Fe Trail)
  • Please Attend and help us show the Legislature we don't want this!
  • Deliver a letter to your legislators.
  • Come early, as parking near the Round House is very hard to find.
The 2007 New Mexico Legislative Session has begun, and one major, problematic bill that we expect to be introduced soon is a huge incentive for a giant coal-fired power plant in New Mexico. This plant will spew over 10 million tons of greenhouse gases into the atmosphere each year, essentially wiping out New Mexico's attempts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions for decades to come. Desert Rock is just one of over 150 coal-fired plants that the cynical coal industry is attempting to rush into construction before Congress imposes limits on greenhouse gas emissions. Protests have erupted across the US to stop these plants, including in conservative states like Texas, where an alliance of mayors is opposing 12 proposed plants. The company proposing Desert Rock, Sithe Inc., claims the plant will be "clean". Such is not the case: It will still spew over 10 million tons of CO2 per year, and it appears that Sithe is hiding other pollution emissions with misleading analysis and taking credit for emission reductions at other plants. This IS a renewable energy/energy efficiency issue: Serious development of large-scale "Concentrating Solar Power", or"CSP" is now possible and is finally beginning in the West. PV is really taking off. We believe a combination of CSP, PV, wind power, and strong efficiency programs could meet most or all of the load growth in the near term. But inappropriate plants such as Desert Rock will suppress that possibility by diverting rate payer money to the wrong places. At the Rally you will:
  • Hear environmental leaders describe why Desert Rock is bad news for New Mexico
  • Help us demonstrate that New Mexican's don't want Desert Rock.
  • Deliver your views to your legislators in person
We suggest bringing signed letters to the event. A template for these is given below. More information about Desert Rock is also given below. You can quickly find your representatives by visiting the website www.vote-smart.org, and entering your zip code. For more information about the Rally, contact Robb Thomson ( robbm@toast.net ) Rally Coordinators are:
-Robb Thomson ( robbm@toast.net )
-Lori Goodman
-Ben Luce
-Holly Beaumont Desert Rock Power Plant:
Summary of Issues

Both scientific studies (IPCC and others) and the economic study on global warming by Stern point to the next decade as being a crucial period during which serious green house gas mitigation must be instituted, or serious risks from global warming will result. Instead of initiating a path for decreasing green house gas emissions in the State, Desert Rock would INCREASE the total net emissions in the State by an estimated 16%. This magnitude of increase could not be counteracted by other mitigation policies for the better part of that crucial decade described above. And in particular, the savings proposed by the Governor to take action by 2012 are almost exactly the amount that Desert Rock will increase those emissions, once it is fully operational.

Mercury is a serious health hazard in NM, and mercury emissions by Desert Rock will not be controlled by present EPA stance. Uncontrolled, Desert Rock would increase mercury emissions in the state by about 40%. Overall levels of controlled pollutants will put the 4 Corners region over the top on EPA air quality standards if Desert Rock is built. The disposal of fly ash from pollution control processes could pose a serious health hazard, but is not a controlled standard.

The accuracy of all the submitted figures for pollutant control at Desert Rock have been seriously questioned by expert testimony from Dine Care, San Juan Citizens Alliance, et al. The EPA judges Desert Rock on the basis of “Best Available Control Technology”, but did not allow comparisons to Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle systems. IGCC is significantly better than the traditional Desert Rock plan ON ALL COUNTS. (For example, mercury can be practically eliminated entirely, CO2 emission is lower, and ultimate CO2 capture is fi- nancially feasible.) An IGCC plant would therefore significantly ameliorate the problems associated with building a new electric power plant in the 4 Corners.

An even better alternative to Desert Rock than IGCC is a concentrated solar power system, which has NO environmental downsides. It would also create jobs in the Navajo Nation, just as Desert Rock does.

Desert Rock Facts and Statistics

Owners: Sithe Global Power of Houston, TX.

Electricity Production: 1500 MW (two 750 MW units),

Expected electric energy produced per yr for Desert Rock is 11,169 GWh.

Total electric energy produced in NM in 2003 was 32,500 GWh.

Cost: $2.2 Billion

Fuel: Coal (mine mouth facility)

Location: 580 acres about 30 mi S of Shiprock

CO2 emissions: 10.5 MMtCO2e per year.

Desert Rock is proposed by Sithe in partnership with Dine Power Authority (a Navajo nation enterprise). It will be a “market plant” which means it will sell power to other buyers. Sithe claims prospective buyers will be APS the Salt River Project and PNM (PNM denies they will buy power from Desert Rock). The land is leased to Dine Power and subleased to Sithe. Sithe has brokered a 67% reduction of taxes from the Nation, and is in negotiation with the County for additional tax breaks. A bill is expected to be introduced in the Legislature for substantial relief from State taxes. (Last year, the total amount of such tax relief requested was $60M over a period of about 5 years.)

SAMPLE LETTER

February 5, 2007

The Honorable ________
NM State Senate/House of Representatives
State Capitol
Santa Fe, NM 87501

Dear Senator/Rep _____

I am one of your constituents, and write regarding my opposition to the building of a large new coal fired electric plant at Desert Rock.

I have been delighted by the leadership the Legislature has provided our state in the area of global warming, and your support of proposals to mitigate the growth of green house gases. And in particular, I am pleased by the Governor's recently announced program, based on the recommendations of his Climate Change Advisory Group.

But the plan to build the Desert Rock power facility will deal a fatal blow to the Governor's program, because it will totally wipe out the planned savings in green house emissions in 2012 relative to the reference year 2000. According to climate change experts, we have about a decade to deal effectively with green house gas emissions in a serious way, before we risk serious consequences to the climate. If Desert Rock is built, in New Mexico, we will have lost most of that decade.

In addition to the emission of green house gases, Desert Rock is also a matter of concern to New Mexicans because of the damage it will do to an already stressed environment in the 4Corners region. And more particularly, we are concerned by the emission of mercury from the stacks. Mercury is already a serious health issue in the state, and the additional 40% burden from Desert Rock would be unacceptable, in my opinion.

The major benefit quoted by the supporters of the plant is the economic benefit to the Navajo Nation and its citizens, but there are alternative ways to build new power capacity in the State without causing unacceptable environmental harm to the State and all its citizens.

Thus, I believe that the Desert Rock plant, as proposed, will be harmful to the people of the State, represents bad public policy, and should not be built. I respectfully request that you oppose the granting of tax credits or any other benefits to the builders and owners by the State in any way you can.

Very sincerely yours,

(For more information on "Desert Rock Power Plant" go to:
ALERTS_Dine_Blockade.html)

PRINTABLE PAGE

 


DESERT ROCK UPDATE & MEDIA ALERT!!!!
http://www.desert-rock-blog.com

Dine Blockade Dec. 21, 2006 <- (look for more update)

INDIGENOUS ENVIRONMENTAL NETWORK ALERT!
Please send far and wide!!!!

URGENT Support is requested from Dine Elders and Youth!

Sithe Global & DPA are proposing to build the Desert Rock power plant, a 1,500 MW Coal Fired plant in the Four Corners area on the Navajo Reservation. This is an area already polluted by 2 other major coal power plants. Local Navajo residence and community members oppose this project for many harmful reasons!! This Desert Rock power plant is still in the environmental review process and has NOT yet been permitted.

However, Desert Rock company trucks have began moving onto the backyard of Alice Gilmore, an elderly navajo woman, and her family on wednesday to begin drilling efforts. Desert Rock officials and police have not shown any documents or permits to the local residents stating their purpose or permission to be there. Dine supporters and community members have joined Alice and her family to blockade the road. They are elderly women and youth, and they have been camped out on the road over night since Tuesday! Desert Rock trucks have repeatedly rushed them and have almost run-over people a number of times as they attempt to get by. Desert Rock power company is violating the lease rights of the local Navajo residences and is harassing elderly Navajo women and youth! This is an urgent time and support is needed!!!

Please read on to find out how you can help! and Please pass this onto others!

(press release and additional article)

Lucy A. Willie, right, stands at the proposed Desert Rock Power Plant site outside of Burnham on Wednesday where she and several friends and family stayed overnight to stop a contractor for Desert Rock Energy Company from doing preliminary work.
What they need: * More People Support  
* Fire wood  * $$

*
* Attention! **
how You can Help! **More People!

More people are needed to sit in support! All are welcome! directions to the area are below:
The site is between Gallup, NM and Shiprock, NM (northeastern, NM). Take the road between Gallup and Shiprock, the 491. at the Mustang Service Station (one of the only service stations between the two), turn East on road #5 towards Burnham Chapter. From Burnham Chapter turn North onto gravel road #5082. About 10-12 miles up the road turn West until you see the encampment. There will be markers (balloons) out on the roads. (if you begin to see a dragline, you've gone too far)

- Fire wood! it is cold outside and many of the resisters are elderly women. if you can get firewood to the site it is very very much needed! the directions to the site are above.

- $ Money! Resisters are in need of money for gas and food, and also for bail money if necessary. Please send donations to local resident and supporter:
Elouise Brown
1015 Glade Lane 34
Farmington, NM 87401 Elouise can also be reached at: thebrownmachine@hotmail.com

- ATTENTION! the more media and observers are present the least likely Desert Rock is likely to run people over or harass them. contact the media, tell them what is going on. Contact Navajo Authorities, tell them you are extremely concerned. Be a legal observer. Spread this Alert!

Media Contact: Lori Goodman, cell #: (970) 759-1908, e-mail address: kiyaani@frontier.net

Contact the Following Authorities! Tell them you have heard about Desert Rock's harassment of Navajo elders and youth. Tell them you are extremely concerned! If enough people contact these offices they will know that the world is watching.

Shiprock Police Department phone: (505) 368-1350
fax: (505) 368-1293

Navajo Nation President Joe Shirley's Office
P.O. Box 9000 Window Rock, Arizona, 86515
phone #: (928) 871- 6352

also: George Hardeen, Navajo Nation Communications Director Office of the President
Office #: 928-871-7000  Cell #: 928-380-7688 e-mail: georgehardeen@opvp.org

Bureau of Indian Affairs (Gallup Office) they are conducting the Environmental Impact Statement.
Harrilene Yazzi, NEPA Coordinator Bureau of Indian Affairs, Navajo Regional Office
P.0. Box 1060 Gallup, New Mexico 87305 Phone: 505-863-8314  Fax: 505-863-8324

Be a Legal Observer - get to the site and help record/witness what is happening

Send this Action Alert Far and Wide!

Thank you for your support!!!
Enei Begaye , Executive Director
Black Mesa Water Coalition
408 E. Route 66, Suite #1
Flagstaff, AZ 86001 Office #: (928) 213-9760

Jihan Gearon, Native Energy Campaign
Indigenous Environmental Network
(877) 436-2121

PRESS RELEASE Wednesday, December 13, 2006
Contacts:
Sarah Jane White, Doodá Desert Rock Committee (505) 860-6166
Dailan J. Long , Diné CARE, Doodá Desert Rock Committee (505)801-0713
Elouise Brown, Doodá Desert Rock Committee (505) 974-6159
Lori Goodman, Diné CARE (970) 759-1908

BURNHAM, SANOSTEE & NENANEZAH RESIDENTS BLOCKADE DESERT ROCK PROJECT

Burnham, NM --Burnham, Sanostee & Nenanezah Elders and citizens are braving the cold to protect the land from the encroaching Diné Power Authority (DPA) and Sithe Global LLC at the proposed Desert Rock site. Navajo residents confronted the Diné Power Authority/Sithe Global on Tuesday afternoon after learning of water drilling that had been occurring without the knowledge and notification of local residents.

“I have said ‘No’ over and over again and you keep coming over!” Nenanezah elder Alice Gilmore exclaimed to Sithe/DPA employees at the confrontation. For Gilmore, the issue is despicable and uncalled for since she gave no consent to allow DPA/Sithe into her grazing area. Members of the Doodá Desert Rock committee gathered to support her opposition and asked Sithe/DPA to disclose Drilling permits that allowed drilling activity to occur, to no avail. The residents refused to leave after the Navajo Nation Police attempted to give access to DPA/Sithe Global, claiming that permits for the Desert Rock project are not for public disclosure. The Burnham residents barricaded the roads to disallow traffic into the Desert Rock site and have remained in place since the Tuesday incident occurred.

Members of Diné CARE/Doodá Desert Rock Committee met this morning at the Shiprock Courthouse to get answers about drilling permits yet the Lieutenant Dempsey denied access to Gilmore and other concerned residents to view the permits. Residents are asking for: 1.) A copy of the categorical exclusion that is allowing the drilling activities to commence. 2.) Copies of the Clean Water Act Sections 401, 402 and 404, that would prove compliance with regulatory requirements have been met. There are major disturbance taking place and according to the Clean Air Act, these permits are a pre-requisite for drilling activity.

The proposed area is home to extended families, but arbitrarily drawn political boundaries by the Navajo Nation and company representatives have the families separated into the three chapters: Burnham, Sanostee, and Nenahnezad. The boundary defining Burnham and Nenahnezad has been moved south for benefit of DPA/Sithe as recently as two years ago.

“The local residents are not protesters but are resisters. Who would be happy if a well is being dug in their backyard especially when it is done in secrecy? So, how can those residents be considered protesters when they are simply standing up for their rights to have clean air, water, and environment.” Stated, Elouise Brown of Sanostee.

Burnham, Sanostee and Nenanezah residents are not waiting for remedy; many have set up camp at the proposed site and are refusing to move until they get the needed documents. “We’re fed up with them,” states Sarah J. White, President of the Doodá Desert Rock Committee, “the grandmas and the grandpas are being walked over by these monsters and they’re being denied information. We’re standing our ground now.” This incident follows accusations made against Sithe/DPA about environmental injustices, EPA’s proposed issuance of prevention of significant deterioration (PSD) permit Air Quality Permit for Desert Rock Energy Facility and the creation of Navajo Nation Energy Policies without public input. ###

Lori Goodman,
Dine' CARE ,
10 A Town Plaza, PMB 138, Durango, CO 81301
PH: (970) 259-0199, FAX: (970) 259-2300, Cell: (970) 759-1908
kiyaani@frontier.net ,dinecare.org

 

NAVAJO TRADITIONAL ELDERS BLOCKADE POWER PLANT SITE

By Brenda Norrell U.N. OBSERVER & International Report

BURNHAM, NEW MEXICO, USA – Elderly Navajo women and their children formed a blockade, built a fire and camped at the site of a proposed power plant on tribal land in northwest New Mexico. The blockade of traditional Navajos halted site work in a region that is already toxic with air and water pollution from power plants, oil and gas wells and scattered radioactive tailings from the Cold War.

Facing the threat of arrest by tribal police at the blockade, Navajo elderly, including one medicine man, said they are willing to go to jail to protect their land and way of life.

Most of the elderly are already ill from living in an area where power plants have released 100 tons of coal combustion waste that is blowing in the wind. One of the Navajo elderly resisters is in a wheelchair and another has severe asthma.

For the second night on Wednesday night, Dec. 13, Navajo resisters camped in the cold at the site. “I have said ‘No’ over and over again and you keep coming over!” said Nenanezah elder Alice Gilmore, who holds the grazing permit for the area of the proposed Desert Rock Power Plant. The Navajo Nation and Sithe Global LLC plan to build the power plant, which would be the third power plant in the Farmington/Bloomfield area.

Confronting Sithe and Navajo DPA employees, Gilmore was adamant that she has not given permission for the power plant on her land. Navajo elders from Burnham, Sanostee and Nenanezah chapter, all taking a bold action to fight the tribal government and corporate aggression, joined Gilmore at the blockade.

“We’re fed up with them,” said Sarah J. White, president of the Doodá Desert Rock Committee. “The grandmas and the grandpas are being walked over by these monsters and they’re being denied information. We’re standing our ground now.”

White said Navajos at the barricade need everything in the way of food, firewood and supplies. “We need everything from A to Z,” White said.

The blockade was formed just 10 days after Navajo Nation elected leaders gathered with representatives from 14 countries and formulated a global ban on uranium mining on Native lands. The power plant blockade also comes as Navajo Nation leaders are fighting in the federal Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals to protect San Francisco Peaks near Flagstaff, Ariz., from the desecration of snowmaking from recycled wastewater for tourism. The mountain is sacred to 13 area Indian tribes.

However, both Navajo President Joe Shirley, Jr., and the Navajo Nation Council support the construction of the Desert Rock Power Plant and accompanying coalmine, which Navajos say would add more pollution to the air, land and water, already saturated with disease-causing toxins.

The Navajo Nation tribal government has attempted to censor the voices of Navajos speaking out against the Desert Rock power plant in New Mexico and the use of aquifer water for coal mining by Peabody Coal on the western side of the Navajo Nation in Arizona. The proposed site of the new Desert Rock power plant is in the Four Corners Region, targeted since the 1970s as a national sacrifice area for energy production.

It is also the sacred region of Dinetah, the place of origin of Navajos. However, the air is so polluted in the region of Dinetah near Bloomfield that persons with asthma and respiratory diseases find it difficult to breathe.

Further, Navajos say while they struggle with respiratory diseases, cancer and the death of their loved ones in this region, many Navajos must also haul water and live without electricity, since the power plants on Navajo land primarily provide electricity for non-Indians.

The Navajo blockade comes as O’odham in Sonora, Mexico, challenge a secret plan by the government of Mexico, with the knowledge of the USEPA, to create a hazardous waste dump near the sacred site of Quitovac where O’odham hold ceremonies. The Navajo blockade coincides with an action by Pima on Gila River tribal land in Arizona to halt expansion of a hazardous dumpsite.

At the same time, Yaqui in Sonora, Mexico, gathered to prohibit the use of banned pesticides in agricultural fields, now resulting in cancer and deaths.

At the proposed new Desert Rock power plant site in New Mexico, Navajo residents confronted the Diné Power Authority/Sithe Global on Dec. 12, after discovering that water drilling was carried out without the knowledge and notification of local Navajo residents. Members of the Doodá Desert Rock committee gathered to support Gilmore’s opposition and asked Sithe/DPA to disclose drilling permits that allowed drilling activity to occur. However, no permits were provided.

The residents refused to leave after the Navajo Nation Police attempted to give access to DPA/Sithe Global, claiming that permits for the Desert Rock project are not for public disclosure. The Burnham residents barricaded the roads to disallow traffic into the Desert Rock site and Navajos remained at the blockade.

Members of Diné CARE/Doodá Desert Rock Committee met Dec. 13, at the Shiprock tribal courthouse to get answers about drilling permits.

Navajo residents said a tribal police lieutenant denied Gilmore and other residents access to view the permits. Navajo residents are asking for a copy of the categorical exclusion, which would allow the drilling activities to commence, and copies of the Clean Water Act Sections 401, 402 and 404, that would prove compliance with regulatory requirements have been met.

“There are major disturbance taking place and according to the Clean Air Act, these permits are a pre-requisite for drilling activity,” Navajo residents said in a public statement. Further, Navajos say tribal boundary lines were redrawn to accommodate the power plant corporation. The proposed area is home to extended families, but arbitrarily drawn political boundaries by the Navajo Nation and company representatives have the families separated into the three chapters: Burnham, Sanostee, and Nenahnezad.

Navajo residents said the boundary defining Burnham and Nenahnezad was moved to the south for the benefit of DPA/Sithe within the past two years.

Elouise Brown of Sanostee said, “The local residents are not protesters but are resisters. Who would be happy if a well is being dug in their backyard especially when it is done in secrecy? So, how can those residents be considered protesters when they are simply standing up for their rights to have clean air, water, and environment.”

Burnham, Sanostee and Nenanezah residents are not waiting for remedy; many have set up camp at the proposed site and are refusing to move until they get the needed documents.

Navajos said this incident follows accusations made against Sithe/DPA about environmental injustices, EPA’s proposed issuance of prevention of significant deterioration (PSD) permit Air Quality Permit for Desert Rock Energy Facility and the creation of Navajo Nation Energy Policies without public input.

PRINTABLE .html

 

Persistent Organic Pollutants (POP’s) IEN would like to ask your help in stopping the U.S. Congress from weakening our ability to regulate dangerous chemicals. These chemicals, called POPS, include dioxins, PCB’s and pesticides, and are extremely toxic and pose significant environmental and human health risks. ..
. html , .doc, or .pdf